Free Web Hosting by Netfirms
Web Hosting by Netfirms | Free Domain Names by Netfirms

 

 

WOMEN, WORK, GLOBALIZATION

 

 

 

Research of the Agency for social analyses (ASA) and “WAD” Foundation

Leaded by prof. Dr.Lilia Dimova

Supported by UNIFEM

 

 

November 2001

Contents

RESEARCH METHODOLOGY 3

SATISFACTION WITH THE CHANGES 4

ATTITUDE TOWARDS THE PRIORITIES OF STATE POLICY *

ATTITUDE TOWARDS PROCESSES OF GLOBALIZATION *

POVERTY AS A NATIONAL PROBLEM *

POVERTY INDEXES 8

OPTIMISM INDEXES 9

ACTIVITY INDEXES 10

ATTITUDE TOWARD DISCRIMINATORY PRACTICES *

"DISLOYAL RIVALRY" OF WOMEN ON THE LABOUR MARKET *

JOB PREFERENCES *

DISTRIBUTION OF HOUSEHOLD LABOUR 14

BREAKING UP TRADITIONALISM *

 

 

 

 

RESEARCH METHODOLOGY

Sample

National representative survey of the whole Bulgarian population

Sample size –1144, aged 18 or older

Research method

Individual face-to-face standardized interview by living place of residence

Standard error

± 2,5 %

 

SATISFACTION WITH THE CHANGES

A comparatively small part of both men and women are satisfied with the changes in the economy, their quality of life and political situation in the country. Those who are discontented are considerably more.

Most massive is discontent in regard of quality of life. Nearly two thirds of the people are dissatisfied with their standard of living. Survey registers that 63% of both men and women now live worse than before the beginning of transformations. Every forth man and every third woman assess their living standard as lower than the standard of their mothers when they were their age.

However, in reference of gender equality in the country, positive attitudes dominate over negative. Current “level of equality” is more favourable for men than for women.

Table 1. Degree of satisfaction with the changes (%)

Satisfaction with……

Satisfied

Neither satisfied,nor dissatisfied

Dissatisfied

Ì

F

Ì

F

Ì

F

…own quality of life

17,1

14,7

21,1

20,9

61,2

63,1

… political situation

16,5

12,2

24,5

26,1

43,1

43,2

…gender equality

46,6

38,1

24,4

21,5

15,9

27,2

… ongoing reforms

17,6

14,8

23,6

19,8

45,3

49,3

 

ATTITUDE TOWARDS THE PRIORITIES OF GOVERNMENTAL POLICY

Data show a great gap between people’s priorities and the agenda of political elite. There are strong differences in ranging “real” and “desired” political orientations.

Most both men and women point out Euro-integration and NATO accession as leading in the current political orientation.But they are rather in the rear on expectation scale. One of the reasons is the so called “language gap” between governors and governed. Other reason is highly polarized society into “THEM” and “US”, i.e. “politicians” and “ordinary people”.

Improving of the living standard, economic stabilization, struggle with crime and corruption, employment are the priorities which according to public should lead the governmental policy.

Table 2. Real and desirable priorities of governmental policy

Priorities

Real priorities

Desirable priorities

Rang total

%

Rang male

Rang female

%

Male

Female

Male

Female

Euro-integration

1

42,2

34,2

9

10

10,7

7,4

Membership in NATO

2

42,3

32,9

13

14

4,3

0,9

Economy

3

39,3

32,6

2

2

57,6

54,9

Corruption

4

27,6

24,5

4

6

26,5

20,1

Criminality

5

21,8

20,0

5

4

25,8

29,1

Living standard

6

22,5

15,4

1

1

61,3

57,7

Financial stabilization

7

19,3

18,1

6

7

17,8

15,0

Employment

8

12,1

10,0

3

3

36,8

31,9

National interests

9

11,3

10,5

8

11

11,7

7,0

Health care

10

8,2

11,1

7

5

17,0

21,6

Education

11

3.2

3.0

12

12

5,9

7,0

Children and youths

12

1.8

4.4

10

8

8,2

11,2

Adults

13

1.5

3.4

11

9

7,0

11,0

Sport

14

1.1

0.6

15

15

0,3

0,0

Culture

15

0.2

0.3

14

13

1,8

2,4

Can not estimate

 

11,6

23,3

   

1,1

6,0

*The interviewed has given to three answers on account of which the total per cent exceeds 100.

ATTITUDE TOWARD THE GLOBALIZATION’S PROCESSES

The evaluations of advantages and disadvantages of globalization are contradictory and are based on myths rather than real arguments. Positive judgements prevail “in principle”: that multinational companies are good for the economy (64.1% men and 44.2% women), that Bulgaria will win from Euro-integration (64.1% men and 52.1% women). Membership in NATO will raise the national security consider 47.3% from men and 35.6% from women. It is also appraised the greater political freedom as a result from the democrartic changes in the country.

Negative attitudes toward crime and globalization prevail, the reserves to the movement of work force to our country are relatively high.

Data discover strong attitudes toward potential immigration.

Table 3. To what extent do you agree with the following statements? (%)
 

Statements

Agree

Neither agree, nor disagree

Disagree

Can’t choose

Ì

F

Ì

F

Ì

F

Ì

F

1.

Now women have more political freedom

47,2

39,0

20,1

18,1

19,9

27,9

12,8

15,0

2.

Privatized enterprises work better than before

11,5

18,8

14,8

11,9

41,6

35,6

32,1

45,3

3.

It is necessary to improve the living standard of people in Bulgaria in order to become an EU members

89,5

80,4

1,1

2,1

2,1

0,9

7,3

16,6

4.

Bulgaria should limit the foreign products in order to protect its national economy

66,0

64,6

13,3

8,5

14,8

10,4

6,0

16,5

5.

Foreigners should not be allowed to buy land in Bulgaria

49,4

41,4

16,5

14,3

24,8

22,9

9,4

21,4

6.

Immigrants would take jobs away from Bulgarians

53,2

42,6

10,4

12,2

16,7

14,5

19,8

30,7

7.

I am willing to move to another European country

36,4

34,7

7,3

3,2

55,4

58,6

0,8

3,5

8.

I am willing to advise a young person to move to another European country

61,2

55,3

5,4

5,8

25,8

31,7

7,6

7,2

9.

Multinational companies are something good for Bulgarian economy

56,0

44,2

15,7

13,4

7,3

9,4

20,9

33,0

10

New technologies would increase the number of jobs

17,0

17,7

13,0

11,5

51,0

38,5

18,9

32,5

Poverty as a national issue

Poverty is one of the strongest negative effects of globalization. In 2001, the structure of Bulgarian society is with insignificant elite at the top, relatively small middle class (22%) and the great mass of people from the middle to the bottom of the social pyramid. Grasped in poverty trap feel 29 per cent of Bulgarian citizens who “live bad” and “hardly meet both ends”. They are mostly pensioners, unemployed, but also 15 per cent of the employee’s. Women are 58 per cent of those who identify themselves as “poor”.

The type of society was different before the beginning of transformations – not many at the top and at the bottom and dominant majority in the middle of the social pyramid.

Respondents’ expectations are that their children will live in a society with many people near the top and only few near the bottom. However, every third of the poor expects his children also to be poor.

Graph 1. Structure of Bulgarian society according to self-estimations of poverty on scale “rich-poor”

 

 

POVERTY INDEXES

Poverty indexes are computed as weighted mean from self-estimations of the surveyed people of their position on 10-point scale “Rich - Poor”.

Poverty indexes vary from 1 to 5. The nearer to 5 is the index value the more negative are the assessments of poverty in the country.

Indexes which gravitate to 1 show maximum closeness to the ideal of “welfare society”.

The tendency for keeping high index levels is a symptom for developing a “culture of poverty”. This culture of poverty is a “design for living” which is transmitted from one generation to the next. If this tendency continues there is a real risk of “second poor generation”, what will be a new phenomenon for Bulgaria.

Graph 2. Poverty indexes by age and by sex

 

Poor

 

Rather

poor

 

Neither rich,

nor poor

Rather

rich

 

Rich

 

OPTIMISM INDEXES

This index shows the judgements of the surveyed individuals of that to what extent, as things are going in Bulgaria, people like them and their families have an opportunity to improve their standard of living.

Optimism indexes assume values from 1 to 3. The nearer to 3 is the value, the more pessimistic public attitudes are.

This index also has similar high values as poverty indexes. The fluctuations in 1997 and 2001 toward greater optimism are based on hopes for better life which people lay on the new governments because of the general elections in those years.

Generally, the indexes for women have insignificantly but higher values as compared with those for men, except for 2000 – this year is characterized with great dissatisfaction with government and the processes in the country, strongly expressed by men.

Graph 3. Optimism indexes by age and by sex

Pessimism

 

 

 

Realism

 

 

 

Optimism

 

ACTIVITY INDEXES

Activity index registers citizens’ individual strategies for coping with the crisis and assumes values from 1 to 3. Values near 1 indicate for active actions and values near 3 – for helplessness and waiting for “help outside”, mostly from the government.

The active strategies include seeking for additional sources of income, mainly in the sphere of alternative “gray” economy. Passive strategies are linked with “fastening the belts” and shrinking the consumption. They prevail in the years of transformations in the country.

Women are comparatively more passive than men are when choosing a strategy for improving their living standard. They rely on their own potential less than men.

Graph 4. Activity indexes

Helplessness

 

 

Passivity

 

 

 

Activity

 

ATTITUDE TOWARD DISCRIMINATION

A considerable portion of both men and women estimates that women in the country are under different discriminatory pressure in the labour market. It is displayed mostly regarding employment, payment, promotion. Differences in evaluations by sex are insignificant.

Things are different in relation to women and dismissals. Under the same risk, men apprehend women rather as sharing the same fate than as victims. However, more women identify themselves as abused again.

 

Graph 5. Public judgements that women are abused regarding…

 

 

 

1… employment

 

2….payment

 

3…dismissals

 

4…holding high posts

 

 

“DISLOYAL RIVALRY” OF WOMEN IN THE LABOUR MARKET

Survey showed that women’s declared payment is lower than that of men. Employed women receive 67% of men’s remuneration. The more interesting thing is that women are more unpretending. That which they consider for a real material equivalent of their work constitutes 54% of that considered as deserved by men.

In comparison with men, women are more inclined to re-qualify and pay for their new qualification, to study during whole their working life, to compromise with household work and taking care of children, to do without free time. As contrasted with women, men more difficult accept any job, although both sexes would do it when pressed to support their family in terms of unemployment.

Table 4. Real and regarded as fair salary

 

Male

Female

Difference

% of male income

Declared average monthly salary

264lv.

176lv.

88lv.

67

Judgements of deserved salary

710lv.

382lv.

328lv.

54

Differences between declared and considered as deserved salaries

- 446lv.

- 206lv.

240lv.

 

% differences between declared and considered as deserved salaries

37

46

   

 

Table 5. To be competitive at the labour market, to what extent are you willing or not…

(% of employed)

 

Willing

Neither willing, nor no

Not willing

 

Ì

F

Ì

F

Ì

F

…to pay for qualification and training

51,3

67,3

20,0

8,2

26,3

21,9

…to study during whole your working life

40,3

58,9

15,4

12,1

42,4

26,8

…to compromise with your family engagements

35,5

46,7

24,6

17,8

36,3

31,0

 

 

JOB PREFERENCES

Data discovered that comparatively most massive are the preferences for working for the government or public service. They are largely linked with the high culture of dependency of people in Bulgaria. According to 73.7% of men and 79.1% of women it should be the government’s responsibility to provide a job for everyone who wants one. 84.2% of men and 85.7% of women think that it is a state’s responsibility to provide for everyone in Bulgaria a minimum guaranteed income.

The other reason is in the “syndrome of subscription” which continues existing in public consciousness. Work for the government is a synonym for “subscription to salary”. It is also linked with greater job security. Good payment and job security are among the main working values.

More men than women are interested in establishing their own business. The “comfort of subordinates” is comparatively much more preferred by women than by men.

Graph 6. Job preferences

  1. Government firm
  2. Bulgarian private firm or joint ventures
  3. Foreign private firm
  4. Own business

 

 

 

DISTRIBUTION OF HOUSEHOLD WORK

Survey registers a strong superiority of women over men in the sphere of “unpaid household work”. On average, women spend over 8 hours more than men on household tasks a week. Most significant are the differences in the category of unemployed where men’s share of household tasks is with 12 hours less than women’s share.

Women continue taking nearly all the responsibility of domestic task – laundry, cooking, shopping, cleaning. The burden of this work has fallen down, on average, over more than other 25% of women only for the last 6 years (in compare to 1995). Men make only small repairs around the house and “help” with the shopping.

Both sexes apprehend this distribution of household work as unfair. Nearly half of women in Bulgaria (48%) belief that at home they do much more than their fair share is. Because of the same reason, every third man has remorses.

Table 6. Hours a week, spend on household work

Category

Men

Women

Difference women/men

Total

13h. 07 m.

21h 19m.

+ 8h. 12m.

Employed

11h. 23m.

18 h. 12m.

+ 6h. 53m.

Unemployed

13h. 38m.

25h. 52m.

+ 12h. 14m.

Pensioners

15h. 34m.

23h. 32m.

+ 7h. 59m.

 

Graph 7. Fairness of distribution of household work (%)

  1. I do much more than it is fair
  2. I do roughly what is fair
  3. I do much less than it is far

 

BREAKING up TRADITIONALISM

A great number of men in Bulgaria, mainly from older generations, still consider home and family to be the supreme value for women. However, fewer women think in this way.

Breaking in the traditional believes of division of gender roles is observed. The untraditional in women is more strongly exprssed.

The judgements that both men and women should contribute to household income are massive. The reasons are in women’s employment which has turned into public norm, as well as in the hardship circumstances in which Bulgarian families are nowadays.

The contribution of men to the unpaid household work is insufficient. Predominant are the attitudes that men should not be entirely devoted to their job but to do a larger share of domestic task and of childcare.

Table 7. Level of agreement with the statements

Statements

Agree

Neither agree, nor disagree

Disagree

Male

Female

Male

Female

Male

Female

A job is all right, but what most women really want is a home and children

57,3

52,4

19,5

23,2

13,2

19,5

Being a housewife is just as fulfilling as working for pay

51,5

41,3

18,1

17,9

20,3

36,3

Having a job is the best way for a woman to be an independent person

64,1

75,0

18,5

10,3

9,3

8,3

Both the man and woman should contribute to the household income

85,1

88,6

1,0

6,9

3,1

2,4

A man’s job is to earn money; a woman’s job is to look after the home and family

47,5

36,6

26,1

26,7

24,9

33,6

Men ought to do a larger share of household work than they do now.

52,2

72,0

27,0

18,0

14,2

5,8

Men ought to do a larger share of childcare than they do now.

71,1

83,3

20,3

10,0

3,7

2,9

back to the top